Interesting challenge. - This is an example of why, when taking photos which I know will require some Keystone correction in post processing, I always include too much. - ie Zoom out.
As usual for me now, I first ran the RW2 file through DxO PureRAW 3 for both noise reduction (not that there was much) and lens correction purposes, before importing the resulting DNG file into Capture One Pro 23.
Performed 100% Keystone correction, but this cropped out too much and made the extremities of the image look excessively distorted. Wound it back to 80%. - Looked a lot better, but still not ideal. Decided to stick with it though. Adjusted the crop to get the maximum amount of useful information into the image, before fiddling around with White Balance (warmed it up a bit), Exposure, Brightness, Highlight recovery, Shadow recovery and Contrast.
Subscribe to see EXIF info for this image (if available)
The Challenge is now closed. Many thanks go all who have contributed. I thought that this would be easy to judge, but looking at the submissions I see that I was so wrong! I'll try to post the results sometime tomorrow.
Thank you all for submitting your beautiful edits. The photo was taken at a flea market in 2017. I did not find judging this Challenge to be easy, even as there were only four entries. At the outset, I decided that color was important in this particular image. So the choice was among the three color entries. In my (very subjective) view, each entry had its own good points. After going over them many times, and knowing that a choice was necessary, I decided as follows:
Winner: Larry. I liked the bright, airy feeling, the color balance, and the keystone correction.
1st runner up: Ken's first entry. I particularly liked the emphasis on the main subject (the balloon lady) by blurring the background.
2nd runner up: Stiga. I liked the color balance and the brightness.