Do you put borders around your digital photos?

[erictpeterson]

The comment from @WhidbeyLVR got me thinking and I remembered that I had done a comparison of "framed" vs. "unframed" awhile back:

https://etpeterson.com/2024/02/12/shea/

Thoughts on this? Do you like the framed or unframed shots better?

 

[griffljg]

The comment from @WhidbeyLVR got me thinking and I remembered that I had done a comparison of "framed" vs. "unframed" awhile back:
https://etpeterson.com/2024/02/12/shea/

Thoughts on this? Do you like the framed or unframed shots better?

Your link comes up as an email. Here is what I think you were trying to do: Shea

 

[erictpeterson]

Your link comes up as an email. Here is what I think you were trying to do: Shea

Thanks @griffljg ... I fixed it, and yes, Shea. Should be three photos, framed and unframed.

 

[John King]

I have started putting borders around some of my photos and I kind of like the way they look (example below, more at http://etpeterson.com/descansos) but I wondered what other people thought? Does it distract from the photo? Or just waste pixels?

I like the frame in part because when I am using the image as part of a blog post the photo is more clearly framed in the page (e.g., https://etpeterson.com/2025/02/11/ben/)

View attachment 530891

Eric, I use much the same style in my automated Photoshop actions.

I personally like a very fine black line, with a slight drop shadow on the image, then a proportionate white "frame" around it all.

 

[RichardC]

When I use a frame I apply it using the Print module in Lightroom Classic (since it's really easy that way.) I wonder how I could do this in LRC?

There is a watermarking feature in the 'Page' panel inside the LRC print module.

 

[Panolyman]

The comment from @WhidbeyLVR got me thinking and I remembered that I had done a comparison of "framed" vs. "unframed" awhile back:

https://etpeterson.com/2024/02/12/shea/

Thoughts on this? Do you like the framed or unframed shots better?

Oh, framed definitely. 😎

 

[bdbits]

I do not mind a relatively thin border. A big "no" for me on thick borders, especially white (even thin white ones) borders. I use medium and dark themes wherever I can control it, and big white borders are just too much. I have no proof but think it also negatively affects how my eyes see the colors and details in the photo. But that's me, as the photographer you should do you.

 

[MountainMan79]

I started using a frame religiously a few years back. My “rule of thumb” for me is typically plain white for a color photo, and white with a thin black line for b&w. I used a thick frame for 1x1, a normally weighted frame for native aspects like 4x3 and 2x3, and a thin frame for 16x9 and 65x24. Just what I prefer, but don’t think there is a correct option. However, in dark mode online, a frame is very nice imo, and perhaps why I started using one all the time, as that’s how I browse.

 

[erictpeterson]

I started using a frame religiously a few years back. My “rule of thumb” for me is typically plain white for a color photo, and white with a thin black line for b&w. I used a thick frame for 1x1, a normally weighted frame for native aspects like 4x3 and 2x3, and a thin frame for 16x9 and 65x24. Just what I prefer, but don’t think there is a correct option. However, in dark mode online, a frame is very nice imo, and perhaps why I started using one all the time, as that’s how I browse.

I like that! I have just used the same wider frame for any dimensions but I like the idea of different dimensions for different colors and sizes. Thanks for the reply!

 

[Jakesome]

I have started putting borders around some of my photos and I kind of like the way they look (example below, more at http://etpeterson.com/descansos) but I wondered what other people thought? Does it distract from the photo? Or just waste pixels?

I like the frame in part because when I am using the image as part of a blog post the photo is more clearly framed in the page (e.g., https://etpeterson.com/2025/02/11/ben/)

Borders can be a vibe, but it really depends on the context. Here’s the lowdown:

1. Aesthetic Appeal: Borders can make photos pop, especially on blogs or websites, by creating a clear separation from the background. Your example looks clean and intentional, so it works.
2. Distraction Factor: If the border is subtle (like yours), it usually doesn’t steal the show. But if it’s too thick or flashy, it can pull focus from the image itself. Yours seems to strike a good balance.
3. Pixel Usage: Sure, borders “waste” a few pixels, but if it enhances the presentation, it’s worth it. Most viewers won’t notice or care about the lost space if the overall look is sharp.
4. Consistency: If you’re using borders across your blog or portfolio, it creates a cohesive style. That’s a win for branding and visual flow.
5. Audience Preference: Some folks love borders; others don’t. Since it’s your art, go with what feels right to you. If you dig it, that’s what matters most.

TL;DR: Your borders look classy and purposeful. If they make your photos stand out and fit your blog’s vibe, keep rocking them.

 

[erictpeterson]

Borders can be a vibe, but it really depends on the context. Here’s the lowdown:

1. Aesthetic Appeal: Borders can make photos pop, especially on blogs or websites, by creating a clear separation from the background. Your example looks clean and intentional, so it works.
2. Distraction Factor: If the border is subtle (like yours), it usually doesn’t steal the show. But if it’s too thick or flashy, it can pull focus from the image itself. Yours seems to strike a good balance.
3. Pixel Usage: Sure, borders “waste” a few pixels, but if it enhances the presentation, it’s worth it. Most viewers won’t notice or care about the lost space if the overall look is sharp.
4. Consistency: If you’re using borders across your blog or portfolio, it creates a cohesive style. That’s a win for branding and visual flow.
5. Audience Preference: Some folks love borders; others don’t. Since it’s your art, go with what feels right to you. If you dig it, that’s what matters most.

TL;DR: Your borders look classy and purposeful. If they make your photos stand out and fit your blog’s vibe, keep rocking them.

I think for me "consistency" is the key. I am using (more or less) the same aspect ratio and same border in my photo series on descansos and I think it works. But I'm also always wondering (wife says "overthinking" LOL)

I appreciate your response!

 

[Irene McC]

But I'm also always wondering (wife says "overthinking" LOL)

She's right
😃